
LAKEWOOD UNITED CHURCH OF CHRIST
2601 54th Avenue South St. Petersburg, FL 33712
On land originally inhabited by the Tocabaga
727-867-7961
lakewooducc.org
lakewooducc@gmail.com
Date: August 6, 2023
Scripture Lesson: Genesis 2:15-3:28
Sermon: Origins
Pastor: Rev. Kim P. Wells
School starts this week. I don’t know about the students and teachers, but I know many parents are happy about this! This church has always had several teachers among the members and this is helpful for giving insight into what is going on in schools and the education process. And one thing a teacher will tell you is that if you let a student know that you think that they are not capable, that they are slower, that they are not competent, that they are dumb, it’s very likely that the student will fulfill those low expectations. If a teacher expects a student to behave badly, or to do badly on their assignments, they probably will. Teachers have a lot of power over student achievement through how they message their expectations.
Expect people, in general, to act badly and they are more likely to do just that.
And it turns out, that is kind of how it works out with the doctrine of original sin. This concept, largely based on the story we heard this morning from Genesis, posits that people were born to perfection in Eden. But the serpent enticing Eve to eat the forbidden fruit and to give it to Adam ended all that. And now humanity lives in a state of original sin, sin that is part and parcel of our inescapable human identity. This doctrine holds that original sin defines us. We are essentially disobedient to the will and way of God. And our only way to redemption, salvation, to reconciliation with God, is through the death of Jesus on the cross. He paid for our sins so that we may receive the grace and forgiveness of God.
This doctrine expects the worst from humans. And establishes a transactional framework for the relationship between humanity and God with Jesus paying the debt for humanity. The doctrine of original sin posits a fundamentally depraved humanity and a score-keeping God. And as a teacher can tell you, you are probably going to get what you expect from people.
Expect people, in general, to act badly and they are more likely to do just that.
Original sin basically expects people to be bad. It creates a victim mentality. And that leads to acting out – through violence, greed, abuse on an individual level as well as on a societal level from the Crusades to the Holocaust and beyond.
And with this doctrine rooted in the story of Adam and Eve and the serpent, we see the ravages that it has wrought in terms of sexism, patriarchy, the denigration of women. If people are miserable worms, fallen, fundamentally sinful by nature, then until they are ennobled through the blood of Jesus, they can be treated in a demeaning and degrading manner, especially women since it was Eve, a woman, who brought this whole mess upon us.
The whole system of original sin sets up hierarchies and power dynamics that invite, not surprisingly, abuse and domination. And when it happens, it is justified by the doctrine of original sin. What can you expect? Humanity is fallen, after all.
Some years ago, I went on a spiritual pilgrimage to Scotland with Sue Sherwood, a retired UCC pastor and a member of this congregation, currently serving Trinity UCC here in St. Petersburg. While we were in Edinburgh, we went to visit Philip and Ali Newell, well known theologians of the Celtic tradition. Some of you may have read some of Newell’s books. Sue knew the Newells from attending a retreat that they had led at Ghost Ranch in New Mexico. In the course of the conversation with the Newells, Philip, an ordained pastor in the Church of Scotland, who has been the executive director of the Iona Community, told us that he would not take his son to a church were right up front in the beginning of the service they started by telling him he was, to put it more delicately, a pile of defecation. This was Newell’s take on having a prayer of confession at the beginning of worship every Sunday. Maybe you’ve noticed, we don’t do that here at Lakewood Church.
So how did the church come to embrace this damaging doctrine which continues to pervade Christianity? The concept originated not with Genesis but is associated with St. Augustine of Hippo, a bishop of Africa who lived from 345-430 CE. This doctrine was appealing to church leaders and political/governmental leaders because it created a path for control, punishment, domination, and dependence on the church. The message: You are essentially bad. You need the church, mediating the grace of God through Jesus Christ, to save you from suffering for eternity in hell. This gave power to the church.
We want to be aware that the story of Adam and Eve and the apple was part of Jewish scripture for centuries before the emergence of the Jesus movement. And this was not the way it was used or interpreted. There is no doctrine of original sin in Judaism. In good Jewish fashion, the story was expected to have multiple meanings and it did. It was seen as a myth, a formation story, that helps to explain why things are as they are for humanity in general, and for the Jewish people in particular in a specific historical context. And in the Jewish tradition, in ancient times as well as today, this story is not used to project a doctrine like the Christian concept of original sin. For Jews the story is used to explain free will, choice, curiosity, our proclivity for testing limits, and then in the aftermath of the story, it is used to explain social roles and the human condition.
There have been theologians and mystics throughout the Christian tradition who have also found many messages in this story of Adam and Eve and the serpent and the tree beyond the doctrine of original sin. Among other things, it can be seen as a coming of age story helping humans to understand their free will and its implications.
In his book, Original Blessing: A Primer in Creation Spirituality, Catholic theologian and teacher Matthew Fox makes a case for the fundamental goodness of creation and the human species. He draws on the Bible and theologians throughout church history that have kept alive the essential message that creation and people are good. Yes, people have the capacity for sin. For hurting ourselves. Others. And creation. Absolutely. But the whole enterprise of creation and life is essentially an expression of goodness and love. He posits that a faith rooted in the goodness of people encourages self acceptance, care for others and the earth, creativity, and mutuality. Yes, there is sin. People are not perfect, but they are good. And Fox makes the case that this kind of foundational theology creates a path to beloved community.
At one point in this seminal theological book of the 20th century, Fox tells a story about his dog which helps to shine light on the problems with the doctrine of original sin and the positives of the concept of original blessing. Here’s the story:
“Thomas Aquinas [a 13th century Catholic theologian and philosopher] also taught that people are changed more by pleasure than by anything else. I have often found this to be the case. Take my spiritual director, who is my dog, for example. If he wants to chase a squirrel in the backyard and I don’t want him to, what are my options? Well, there is, because I live in America, the military option: I can shoot him, or the squirrel, or both. I could lock him in a closet; I could reason with him, though I would be sure to lose. My best option is to know him well enough to know a pleasure (blessing) greater to him than chasing a squirrel in the backyard. It happens that I do. To be invited out the front door for a walk is a greater pleasure. The result? He forgets the squirrel in the backyard. Yes, pleasure and blessing will indeed change people and structures. I believe that one price the West has paid for ignoring blessing theology is that Christianity has very few tactics for social change. . .” [Original Blessing: A Primer in Creation Spirituality, Matthew Fox, p. 55.]
I believe the task of the church is to help us understand that we are fundamentally good and that we are eternally loved. Yes, we are imperfect. Yes, we screw things up. Yes, we make mistakes. Individually and as a society. And as a culture. And as a species. We have the capacity for incredible harm and evil. But we are inherently good. And we are created in the image of God, a God that is forgiving, loving, and imaginative. And the church needs to be cultivating that kind of image of humanity. Expecting goodness, compassion, and creativity. And creating a world that encourages that. A reliance on the doctrine of original sin seems to have made a mess of things. Like Matthew Fox, I believe that the church can help to bring the world to health and wholeness through an emphasis on original blessing and not original sin.
We close with inspiring words from the cellist Pablo Casals:
“When will we teach our children in school what they are? We should say to each of them: Do you know what you are? You are a marvel. You are unique. In all of the world there is no other child exactly like you. In the millions of years that have passed there has never been another child like you. And look at your body — what a wonder it is! Your legs, your arms, your stunning fingers, the way you move! You may become a Shakespeare, a Michelangelo, a Beethoven. You have the capacity for anything. Yes, you are a marvel. And when you grow up, can you then harm another who is, like you, a marvel?”
May we teach that not only to students in school but to adults in church. Amen.
A reasonable effort has been made to appropriately cite materials referenced in this sermon. For additional information, please contact Lakewood United Church of Christ.
